I once heard someone say the second worse thing you can do to a hiring manager is to present them with a stack of unqualified resumes. The worst is to track their hiring stats on those candidates. One of the problems I often hear from recruiters and sourcers at prospective customer companies is that they are "caught in the middle." The middle between candidate traffic and hiring manager satisfaction. It seems that the current state of sourcing automation--job boards--is how most company recruiters generate candidates for open positions today. They are barraged with resumes, many of whom aren't really qualified. But the recruiters I talk to are managing 50, 70, I've even heard 100 open positions. So they don't really have the time to appropriately screen the candidates. So in most cases they are passed directly to the hiring manager. (And I can't say I blame them--if I had 70 open positions and was being asked to support 10 to 20 hiring managers I'd be doing the same thing.)
A better approach? Use automation to make the recruiter's job more effective--not harder. By using the career website as the common collection point--regardless of source--a talent pool can be developed for filling a current position as well as future ones. Using candidate self-screening technology will allow the recruiter to establish minimum advertised job criteria to be used as a candidate filter. By taking this step--the applicant traffic can be substantially reduced and the candidates that are screened-in will be qualified. A smart recruiter who works with the hiring manager to develop the screening questions will be sending the hiring manager candidates that meet their first level cut. The recruiter might not even have to touch the candidate initially--they could be routed directly to the hiring manager for feedback on whether to proceed or not. Hiring manager satisfaction will increase.
The talenteer approach to the same problem is to have the pool of candidates from a variety of sources available before the job opens. Then using automated notification to let interesting (matching) candidates know about the position, then use screening to determine their fit. This approach should allow for delivery of qualified applicants to hiring managers in hours or days, instead of weeks. Learn how to use automation to become more effective.